christianmonotheism  resources   get involved   contact us   podcast
Calling Christians Worldwide to Return to the Creed of Jesus

found 21 items matching What is the Holy Spirit?

The Holy Spirit in the Old Testament  [53:34]
by Jesse Acuff rated at 1.3 (7 votes so far)

Repeatedly, the very church that insists that the Holy Spirit is a distinct "person," and the third member of the Holy Trinity, contradicts itself when it states the unadulterated truth. If the Spirit of God was not a person in the Old Testament, it is not a person in the New Testament, and therefore not a member of a so-called Holy Trinity! God does not change to suit the whims and fanciful imaginations of men be they pagan or Christian. There is neither variableness nor shadow of turning with the great Creator God of this universe. However, if there were, and if God, at some point decided that He should become a Trinity on a lark in order to satiate pagan man's inordinate desire to worship Him as such, where is the proof? Such a God would not be deserving of worship. Where indeed can we find in the pages of the Bible during the period between the close of the prophetic age of the Old Testament and the opening of the Messianic age of the New, a clear and precise message calling for a change in the number of the members of the Godhead? We cannot, for there is none.

Is the Spirit a Person in John 14.16?  [< 1 page]
by Jay Dicken rated at 1.6 (6 votes so far)

In John 14:16, 18 notice what Jesus said, “And I will pray the Father, and He will give you another [allos] helper, to be with you forever / I will not leave you desolate; I will come to you.” At Matthew 28:20 Jesus said, “Lo, I am with you always, to the close of the ages.” It is through the coming of this promised helper, the holy spirit, that Jesus comes to them and remains with them (although he is physically absent), hence the use of allos. As said before, the holy spirit is reflective of Personality, in this case, that of Jesus Christ.

The Holy Spirit is Not a Person Distinct From The Father  [10 pages]
by Ray Faircloth rated at 1.6 (6 votes so far)

Evidently the holy spirit is not a 3rd person within the formula of a trinity; but rather is God’s own spirit—His mind powerfully expressed into action as outreach to his creation. Since his exaltation to the right hand of God Jesus also expresses his spirit—his mind into action as outreach to his disciples. Because holy spirit means God’s thoughts (and therefore also Jesus’ thoughts)—His mind projected to the receptive human mind, we can say that we have God’s spirit when we are considering the holy Scriptures i.e. when reading/studying them, discussing them or in living our lives in a way that is in harmony with them, including prayer. In this way we are empowered to do God’s will in its many aspects. Also the spirit of God has such power that it brought the universe into being, and will be the power (in Christ’s hands) that brings “the new heavens and earth” into being in the future.

Does Everyone Believe in the Trinity  [11 pages]
by Anthony Buzzard rated at 1.4 (6 votes so far)

It is customary for students of the Bible to refer to Jesus as God and to insist that belief in a Trinity of three co-equal, co-eternal Persons in the One God is the hallmark of true faith. Many recognized Bible scholars do not think, however, that Jesus is called God, in a Trinitarian sense, in the Scriptures. Distinguished experts on the Bible, past and present, maintain that the doctrine of a Tri-personal God is nowhere taught in Scripture.

Why the Trinity Doctrine Doesn't Make Sense: 5 Reasons   [8:15]
by Nathan Crowder rated at 3.9 (22 votes so far)

The Challenge: Will you ask these five questions of your pastor or trusted Christian expert? Most people just believe in the Trinity because that is how they were raised. Tradition has been passed down from generation to generation and no one seems to be asking whether or not this doctrine is biblical. If you care about this subject, if this is important to you, if you want to know who God really is, then you owe it to yourself to wrestle with these questions. Print off the questions at christianmonotheism.com/questions

Debate: Unitarian vs. Trinitarian  [117:52]
by Sean Finnegan vs. Brant Bosserman rated at 3.9 (32 votes so far)

Presented by Brant Bosserman and Sean Finnegan at the One God Conference, in Seattle, WA on June 1st 2008. The debate was over whether God is a single individual (the Father of Jesus) or if he is a Trinity (three persons in one essence). The debate followed this format:

Introduction by Ken Westby and Tom Bosserman [10 min]

Sean's Opening Statement [20 min]
Brant's Opening Statement [20 min]

Sean's Rebuttal [15 min]
Brant's Rebuttal [15 min]

Sean Cross-Examine Brant [10 min]
Brant Cross-Examine Sean [10 min]

Sean's Closing Statement [5 min]
Brant's Closing Statement [5 min]

The discussion was lively and considerate and I thank Brant for his willingness to engage us on this issue. Unfortunately the recording has some microphone interference during the concluding statements but most of what was said can be understood. Sorry for the inconvenience.

Trinity Discussion on London Radio  [22:07]
by Alex Hall rated at 2.9 (14 votes so far)

Listen to this fast-paced London call in radio show discussion about the Trinity. Alex Hall (theocrat) ably answers many questions while asserting that God is one not three. You can visit Alex's website at GodFellas.org.

The Holy Spirit and Translation Bias (2)  [56:05]
by Sean Finnegan rated at 2.0 (7 votes so far)

Sean Finnegan builds on part one and works through the five primary texts used to prove the personality of the holy spirit on grammatical grounds (John 14.26; 15.26; 16.13; Ephesians 1.14; 1 John 5.7). Next he explains how to understand the spirit based on the whole of the Biblical data and concludes it cannot and should not be locked in the straightjacket of trinitarian dogma. Notes available at http://www.christianmonotheism.com/media/text/Sean%20Finnegan%20--%20Translating%20the%20Holy%20Spirit%202.pdf

The Doctrine of God and Christ  [52:40]
by Steve Katsaras rated at 2.0 (7 votes so far)

Citing more than 60 verses, Steve Katsaras of Australia thoroughly explains the biblical doctrines of God and Christ before telling the story of how these truths were corrupted in the ecumenical counsels of the fourth and fifth centuries.

Yahweh is one, not two or three, and there is no God besides him. The Bible uses singular pronouns in reference to God thousands upon thousands of time, a fact that clearly teaches God is a singular individual. This one God is the eternal, omniscient, omnipotent, and omnipresent creator of heaven and earth.

Jesus is the human mediator who called God his Father. Jesus had a beginning in time and is the miraculously born son of God. Jesus recognized his Father as the only true God who was his superior. Jesus admitted to possessing limited knowledge; he was a mortal man who experienced temptation, hunger, thirst, weariness, suffering, death, and resurrection.

The doctrines of God and Christ mutated over time and continued to develop in new and unbiblical ways after the New Testament was written. Steve talks about the first four ecumenical counsels (Nicea in a.d. 325, Constantinople in a.d. 381, Ephesus in a.d. 431, and Chalcedon in a.d. 451) to demonstrate how these doctrines evolved over time.

The Trinity Defined and Refuted  [73:25]
by Sean Finnegan rated at 3.5 (16 votes so far)

Sean Finnegan describes and refutes the belief of three persons in one godhead including a systematic brief treatment of their co-equal, co-eternal, co-essential nature, and the hypostatic union. Does the Trinity make sense? Is the dogma biblical? Join this tour de force through early Church history and the relevant theological constructs of Christianity's most controversial doctrine.

Debate: Is God One or Three in One?  [143:07]
by Sean Finnegan vs. Russ Dizdar rated at 3.3 (18 votes so far)

Sean Finnegan and Russ Dizdar participate in a debate over the question of who God is. Mr. Finnegan took the affirmative position that the Father is the only true God (cf. Jn 17.3) and Mr. Dizdar, took the traditional position that God is three persons in one essence--the Trinity. The tone was very civil and both sides were able to present their positions.

Unfortunately, the moderator, GeorgeAnn Hughes (founder of The Byte Show) was not able to participate very much because she was having some trouble with her voice. As a result, the participants had to keep track of their own time and took turns presenting their cases. The format of the debate was as follows:

Opening Statements
20 minutes -- Sean Finnegan
20 minutes -- Russ Dizdar

Rebuttals
15 minutes -- Sean Finnegan
15 minutes -- Russ Dizdar

Direct Question and Answers
approximately an hour

If you would like to get in on the discussion visit this blog entry.

On the Errors of the Trinity  [12 mp3s]
by Don Snedeker rated at 3.3 (15 votes so far)

A thorough consideration and refutation of the doctrine of the Trinity. Originally released as 12 tapes but now available on mp3, this series examines the doctrine of the Trinity proposition by proposition. Not only is this series approached from a biblical perspective, Don Snedeker also taps into the rich biblical unitarian resources of several authors from the 19th century. Furthermore, Don works through a number of texts typically used to support the Trinity and he demonstrates their true meaning based on their context. Click on the audio icon above to see the titles for each of the 12 mp3s in this comprehensive examination.

Who or What is the Holy Spirit?  [12 pages]
by Sean Finnegan rated at 3.1 (12 votes so far)

Sean Finnegan surveys both Old and New Testaments in an effort to understand the holy spirit free from the straitjacket of trinitarian dogma.

Unitarianism Explained and Defended  [183:08]
by Anthony Buzzard rated at 3.0 (16 votes so far)

Anthony Buzzard presents the biblical unitarian position and then answers questions from trinitarians for more than two hours. Listen in to an invigorating dialogue that covers most of the big questions that perennially surface in this type of conversation.

The Holy Spirit and Translation Bias (1)  [48:42]
by Sean Finnegan rated at 2.8 (10 votes so far)

Sean Finnegan points out several Scriptures where translators intentionally altered the Bible in order to make it fit their traditional doctrine about the holy spirit. Notes available at http://www.christianmonotheism.com/media/text/Sean%20Finnegan%20--%20Translating%20the%20Holy%20Spirit%201.pdf

I Believe in the Holy Spirit  [33:03]
by Jeff Fletcher rated at 1.0 (5 votes so far)

What exactly is the "Holy Spirit?" Is the Holy Spirit a ghost or something mystical, and why is the Holy Spirit important in a believer's life? Scripture references: Genesis 1:1,2; 1 Corinthians 2:4-12; Numbers 11:24-28; Joel 2:28,29; Luke 1:30-35; 3:21; John 7:37; Acts 1:8; Ephesians 1:13; Romans 8:1; Galatians 5:16-24

Acts 5.3 and the Holy Spirit  [< 1 page]
by Jay Dicken rated at 1.0 (5 votes so far)

Jesus called the holy spirit the “finger of God;” so the holy spirit is God’s instrument of activity, and the Bible associates God’s spirit with His power. Therefore, the holy spirit should not be regarded as a person, whether as part of a trinity or as a totally separate person; but it is reflective of Personality, and that Personality is God (the Father).

Acts 13.1-5 and the Holy Spirit  [< 1 page]
by Jay Dicken rated at 1.0 (5 votes so far)

Here the holy spirit is being used as a means of communication by the Lord. I might say, ‘The radio said that there is going to be rain today.’ Do you conclude from this that the radio is a person? Or that a person is utilizing this mode of communication?

Does the Spirit Have a Will in 1 Corinthians 12.11?  [< 1 page]
by Jay Dicken rated at 1.0 (5 votes so far)

The holy spirit is reflective of Personality, and that Personality can be the Father’s or the Son’s. This principle applies in every context used to prove personality of the holy spirit.

Masculine Pronouns and the Holy Spirit in John  [< 1 page]
by Jay Dicken rated at 1.0 (5 votes so far)

Some foreign languages have what is called grammatical gender, which has nothing to do with personality or sexual gender. For example, in Spanish the word mesa means table and is feminine. But this does not mean that they regard it as a person or as female. The same is true for Bible Greek and Hebrew.



<< back to the options
difficult texts (118) 
Who is Jesus? (73) 
Trinity (57) 
Who is God? (41) 
unitarian texts (35) 
Jesus is Human (25) 
pre-existence (22) 
What is the Holy Spirit? (21) 
three persons (21) 
debates (20) 
Church History (20) 
The Shema (19) 
Old Testament God (19) 
incarnation (18) 
Creed of Jesus (15) 
Jesus is God (15) 
New Testament God (14) 
Jesus as Messiah (13) 
co-eternality (13) 
Jesus is God's Agent (13) 
Nicene Creed (12) 
Jesus' Birth (12) 
Eternal Generation (11) 
Dual Natures (11) 
Elohim (11) 
Jesus had a Beginning (11) 
Faith Story (10) 
Jesus Died (10) 
co-equality (9) 
Singular Pronouns (9) 
Son of God (9) 
Worship (9) 
Echad (9) 
God the Son (8) 
The Word (8) 
Importance of this Truth (8) 
Adoni (7) 
oneness (7) 
Chacedonian Creed (7) 
Idolatry (7) 
Heretics (7) 
Form of God (7) 
Jesus has a God (7) 
Jesus was Tempted (7) 
Creator (7) 
Adam Christology (6) 
Representational Deity (6) 
My Lord and My God (5) 
mistranslation (5) 
atonement (4) 
Apostles' Creed (4) 
Son of Man (4) 
I AM (4) 
Salvation (4) 
Let Us Make Man (4) 
Jesus Only (4) 
Persecution (4) 
Constantinopolitan Creed (4) 
Granville Sharp (4) 
Jesus' Sacrifice for Sin (3) 
The Gospel (3) 
Kenosis (3) 
Paraklete (3) 
Jesus was Worshiped (3) 
Mediator (3) 
Ante Nicene Fathers (3) 
Jewish Roots (3) 
Immanuel (3) 
History of the Trinity (3) 
Resurrection of Jesus (2) 
Wisdom of God (2) 
Angel of the LORD (2) 
Alpha and Omega (2) 
Only Begotten God (2) 
circular logic (2) 
Praying to Jesus (2) 
Open Theism (1) 
Faith of Jesus (1) 
No One Has Seen God (1) 
Jehovah's Witnesses (1) 
Cult (1) 
Agency (1) 
God with Us (1) 
Theos (1) 
Michael Servetus (1) 
Talking to Jesus (1) 
Jesus Forgave Sins (1) 
Jesus Raised the Dead (1) 
Shared Titles (1) 
King of Kings (1) 
translation bias (1) 
Adam Pastor (1) 
Claude of Savoy (1) 
Faustus Socinus (1) 
Laelius Socinus (1) 
Fausto Sozzini (1) 
Lelio Sozzini (1) 
Peter Gonesius (1) 
Georg Schomann (1) 
Racovian Academy (1) 
Racovian Catechism (1) 
Ferenc David (1) 
Andreas Wissowatius (1) 
Socinians (1) 



books

These books, written by people from diverse backgrounds, express the simple truth that God is one. Some of them are more scholary while others are more autobiographical. In addition, a few of them are available to read online. If you would like more in depth treatment of christian monotheism, these books are the next step to take. Note: if you know of other books, not listed here, please leave us feedback.

home | media center | get involved | contact info